Social Security Out of Step with Modern Reproductive Technology
Social Security Administration pays benefits for child born of in-vitro fertilization after death of father only after court appeal
By Neal A. Winston
Jackie is a beautiful 10-year-old. Outgoing and smart, she is the child any parent would just love to have. Her mother and grandparents marvel that she is the very image of her father, Jack. Tragically, Jack died before Jackie was born. An ambulance driver, he was covering on Thanksgiving Day so that another driver could be home with his family when he was instantly killed in an intersection accident.
Jackie’s mother, Ruth, has a rare genetic disorder, and cannot naturally conceive. She received donor eggs from her sister, of which several were fertilized with Jack’s sperm in a lab and frozen after a few days. Then, after months of planning and hormone preparation, the embryo was planted in Ruth’s womb. After two unsuccessful attempts, the couple was ready to try one last time, the Monday after Thanksgiving. After the initial shock of hearing about the accident, Ruth’s first call was to the clinic to stop the embryo preparation.
The following February, Ruth proceeded with a successful preparation and implantation, and in November, Jackie was born. However, when Ruth applied for survivors benefits on Jack’s Social Security record for Jackie, she was denied. Even though Jack’s name was on the birth certificate as the father, the SSA made a determination that since Jack had not expressly stated that he would have wished to support his daughter with Social Security benefits on his earnings record if he had died before the procedure was completed, Jackie was not eligible. (more…)

